Tipperary economy faces a ‘battering from milk price cuts

placeholder image

The deputy president of the ICMSA – the State’s specialist dairy farmer organisation – has warned that the current period of falling milk price is inflicting a battering on Tipperary’s economy.

The deputy president of the ICMSA – the State’s specialist dairy farmer organisation – has warned that the current period of falling milk price is inflicting a battering on Tipperary’s economy.

Pat McCormack, who farms at Greenane, estimates a loss to the local economy of €111.5m compared to last year.

He warned that current Government and EU policy complacency means that these kinds of enormous losses could continue into next year.

Mr McCormack made his calculations on the basis of the number of dairy farmers in the county supplying an average of 300,000 litres and then comparing this year’s price to last before applying TCD’s Prof Alan Mathews’s recommended multiplying factor of 1.7.

He said that while no-one imagined that international dairy markets could be turned around at the “click of a finger”, he was becoming increasingly alarmed by what he termed the “sleepwalking attitude” being displayed by the Department of Agriculture, Marine & Food and, even more so, by the EU Commission.

“ICMSA has always been the voice of the family farm that is the backbone of the rural economy and, more specifically, the family dairy farm.

“We’ve always urged politicians and policymakers to grasp the basic fact that where farm incomes take the kind of battering that we’re seeing just now then not alone does the local economy suffer through falling farm income but, based on the well-established economic principle of the multiplier effect, you see massive falls in the wider local economy as the farmers stop purchasing goods and services in their local communities,” said Mr McCormack before going on to break down the Tipperary figures to illustrate his argument.

“We’ll conservatively put the number of milk suppliers at just 2,000 and we’ll allocate them a yearly production of 300,000 litres, again, a conservative enough figure. We’d estimate that the total amount of milk produced out of Tipperary in 2014 was some 600,000,000 litres, about 12 per cent of the total State production, and at a price of 38.4cpl Tipperary milk production in 2014 earned €242m for the county’s farm families.

“If we use the same figures for this year and take a current price of 28cpl than we see that this year we’ll earn only €176m for the same volume of milk. Tipp’s milk suppliers are down, conservatively, €65.5m.

“The multiplier effect measures how this affects the wider local economy and - again, conservatively – we can multiply that figure by 1.7 as we see that money being spent on local goods and local services.

“I think we’re probably understating the figures by estimating that the loss this year to Tipperary’s local economy will be of the order of €111.5m,” said Mr McCormack, who supplies Tipperary Co-op. The figure for neighbouring Kilkenny is €57m.

“What’s even more frustrating is the non-interference policy that seems to be order of the day as far as the Government and the EU Commission is concerned. We’re just seeing a kind of shoulder-shrugging and ‘shure they’ll come back up again at some stage’ attitude. We don’t think that’s any kind of policy at all.

“What ever happened to the value-added strategy being pursued by all our processors and co-ops where we were going to see a move away from a basic commodity basis and on to a level that was far closer to the final retail price?

“How do our politicians imagine that Tipperary’s critically important dairy sector can survive on the basis of the kind of income volatility that can see a farm family’s income go up or down by €35,000 or €40,000 from year to year.

“We’re going to need help managing that kind of extreme volatility and that’s why we need to see local politicians of all parties get behind the kind of income-smoothing policies ICMSA is urging on the Government in the shape of their Farm Management Deposit Scheme modelled on the successful Australian Government’s income averaging tool,” he said.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice