Tipperary ICMSA ‘perplexed’ by council comments on heavy milk trucks


Tipperary ICMSA has dismissed comments by executives of North Tipperary County Council that milk trucks cause more damage to rural roads than other heavy goods lorries.
Tipperary ICMSA has dismissed comments by executives of North Tipperary County Council that milk trucks cause more damage to rural roads than other heavy goods lorries.
The remarks was passed by Newport area manager Marcus O’Connor and senior engineer Michael F Hayes at a meeting of Newport councillors.
Cllr John “Rocky” McGrath, Cllr Mattie Ryan “Coole” and Cllr John Carroll had put the blame for roads being damaged on Coillte moving heavy loads of timber around rural roads.
“They have to be stopped,” declared Cllr McGrath.
Cllr Ryan asked for weight restrictions on roads and urged that Coillte pay towards maintaining roads.
“They are tearing surfaces off roads,” said Cllr Carroll.
However, Mr O’Connor said that milk trucks were “heavy too and nobody ever complains about them”.
Mr Hayes said that milk truck were more damaging because they were “slewing milk back and forth. They do more damage than a fixed load.”
But Cllr McGrath hit back, saying: “We get taxes from farmers, but we’ve never heard of Coillte giving us anything.”
Meanwhile, the ICMSA Tipperary chair, Seamus Troy from Thurles, responded this week, saying that he and all local farmers would find the remarks “as misguided as they were perplexing”.
Mr Troy said that while the remarks may have been made in an “off-hand” manner they highlighted what the he called a “lamentable” failure to grasp that farming and agri-food wasn’t just one of the main products of the local economy, rather, it is – to a huge degree – the most important basis for most of Tipperary’s economy and commercial activity and had to be viewed in that light.
“I know that people can make these sorts of remarks casually without really thinking about how their comments will be interpreted and perhaps this contribution should be considered in that context.
“For a council official to be so off-hand and seemingly unaware of the fundamental importance of milk production to Tipperary’s economy is, frankly, astonishing.
“Put simply, the basis of the economy of all our villages and rural heartland is our milk production and if the price of that is – as is reported to have been alleged - damage to the roads by the trucks drawing the milk to be processed then, as far as Tipperary ICMSA is concerned, that’s a very small price to be paid.
“I would make two simple observations on the matter and I think we should leave it at that: Firstly, don’t farmers pay road tax as well? Don’t our co-ops and processors pay road tax on their vehicles? We already pay – and pay through the nose – for our use of the roads.
“The second point I’d like to see answered is this: if the council executive is unhappy at the means by which Tipp’s milk is conveyed to the co-ops and processors can he please suggest an alternative method that could be used? Our milk is keeping farming communities in a position to keep rural economies afloat.
“The council should be actively seeking out ways to improve our farming sector and not be indulging in speculation about very minor and irrelevant side-issues in an attempt to deflect attention away from their responsibility to maintain our roads”, said the Tipperary ICMSA chairman.