Sometimes a blue tick, is just a blue tick


Part 2 of Deirdre Ryan’s series on overthinking. This week: mind reading
You send a message and the ticks go blue. No reply. And before you've put the phone down you already know: they're annoyed with you. Something you said. Something you did. You just can't figure out exactly what.
Except you don't know that at all. You've decided it.
Mind reading is one of the most common overthinking patterns there is, and one of the least talked about. It's the habit of assuming you know what someone else is thinking or feeling, usually something negative about you , and then treating that assumption as if it were fact.
It shows up everywhere. The friend who seems quiet at coffee and you spend the rest of the day convinced you've offended her. The colleague who doesn't smile at you in the corridor and you're replaying every interaction you've had with them for the past week. The partner .
who says "I'm fine" in a particular tone and you're already bracing for a conversation you haven't had yet. You're not reading the situation, you're writing a story about it. And the story almost always casts you as the problem.
Here's what makes it so convincing. You're not making it up from nothing. You're picking up on something, be it a tone, a look, a silence, and your brain is filling in the rest. The problem is that the brain tends to fill in the worst version. Especially if you've spent a long time in environments where you had to read the room carefully, and where the atmosphere could shift without warning. That kind of hypervigilance makes sense where it came from, it just doesn't always serve you well in ordinary Tuesday life.
The other thing about mind reading is that it keeps you busy managing something that may not even exist. You adjust your behaviour, you over-explain, you go quiet, you pull back, all in response to a version of events that's happening entirely in your own head. Meanwhile the other person is probably thinking about what to have for dinner.
It's a particular kind of uncomfortable, and a low hum of unease that sits with you for hours. You can't settle, you can't let it go, and you can't explain it to anyone because nothing has actually happened.
So here's something worth trying: the next time you find yourself certain you know what someone else is thinking, just pause and ask: what's the actual evidence for this? Not to dismiss your instincts entirely. Sometimes they're right. But there's a difference between a genuine signal and a story your brain has written to fill a silence.
Most silences are just silences. Most blue ticks are just life getting in the way.
Deirdre Ryan is a psychotherapist with nearly 20 years of experience and Clinical Director