Tipperary man found guilty of assault following row with neighbours over traffic cones


A man who got into an altercation with his neighbours over their use of plastic bollards to protect their cars was convicted of assault by Judge Elxiabeth MacGrath at Nenagh District Court.
Adam Baran of 16 Copperbeech View, Roscrea, had pleaded not guilty to common assault at Copperbeech View, Roscrea, and to threatening, abusive or insulting behaviour at the same location on October 1, 2021.
Margaret Seacy told the court that she and her now deceased partner James Collins had gone shopping that morning when they got a phone call from a neighbour to say Mr Baran was removing the bollards and stacking them.
She said that when she returned home Mr Baran came out of his house and pushed her on the shoulder. He called her a “f***ing pig”.
Ms Seacy said that at around 9pm that night she went out to check on their cars when Mr Baran came out and told her to “get out of the way you f***ing c***”.
Ms Seacy said that she was in the habit of putting the two-foot cones out after one of the cars had been damaged. Mr Baran had complained that they were blocking the view from his window.
She said that she was “terrified and shaken” and “mortified” when Mr Baran called her a “c***”.
She stated that Mr Baran had been intoxicated that day.
Cross-examined by Johnny Spencer, solicitor for Mr Baran, Ms Seacy agreed she had made a complaint to Respond Housing about Mr Baran in the past over him playing loud music but said she had never tried to have him removed from the house.
She also agreed that she had CCTV at her house but had not given it to the gardaí as it was not working at the time.
Ann Hickey, a neighbour, said she had witnessed Mr Baran removing the bollards and had rang Ms Seacy.
She had witnessed an altercation between them and while she had not heard what had been said, Mr Baran had been “face-to-face” with Ms Seacy. She hadn’t seen him push her.
Garda Kieran Young, Roscrea Garda Station, said Ms Seacy and Mr Collins had called to the station and made a statement which Ms Seacy said that Mr Baran had pulled a cone out of Mr Collin’s hand and tried to do the same with her but she had held on to it and he had hit her on the shoulder.
He later became aware of the alleged second incident.
Mr Baran subsequently came to the station and made a voluntary statement in which he said that he would stack the cones because “if everyone put cones out it would look like a building site”.
He denied pulling a cone from Mr Collins’s hand and denied hitting Ms Seacy.
He also denied calling her a “f***ing pig”.
Garda Young said that when Ms Seacy called to the station she was upset and “at her wit’s end”.
Garda Young agreed with Mr Spencer that Mr Baran admitted removing the cones and that an argument had taken place.
In his direct evidence, Mr Baran agreed he should not have removed the cones, but denied using the word “c***”.
Richard Gilsen told the court Mr Baran had come to his house to tell him about the allegations and he (witness) was not aware Mr Baran had drink taken.
“All he did was remove the cones from in front of the window because they obstructed his view,” he said.
Judge MacGrath dismissed the charge of threatening, abusive or insulting behaviour but convicted Mr Baran of common assault as one didn’t have to contact the person to commit the offence.
She adjourned the case to July 27 for a victim personal statement.