Retirements of two Tipperary hurlers are sign of the changing of the guard

Westside says that one of Dan McCormack’s last great moments was in the 2023 championship when he did a powerful man-marking job on Limerick’s Gearoid Hegarty.  Picture: Michael P Ryan/Sportsfileplaceholder image
Westside says that one of Dan McCormack’s last great moments was in the 2023 championship when he did a powerful man-marking job on Limerick’s Gearoid Hegarty. Picture: Michael P Ryan/Sportsfile

'Bonner' Maher and Dan McCormack step down from inter-county hurling

The times they are a-changing, wrote the great Bob Dillon. Change is afoot too in Tipperary hurling. Whether through retirements or omissions, the shape of the Tipperary hurling panel in 2025 is likely to differ significantly from that of 2024.

In one sense it could hardly be otherwise. Liam Cahill has little option but to ring the changes after a 2024 season where the team regressed. Go back with the same formation in 2025 and you’re likely to get the same results.

Patrick ‘Bonner’ Maher’s retirement announcement was no surprise. He was part of that golden generation that emerged in 2009/10 and he outstayed most of them; Noel McGrath now remains the sole survivor from the 2010 All-Ireland team and his future has become an item of speculation too as the winds of change blow through the panel.

‘Bonner’ was a fan favourite. With that left hand on top of the hurley, when ‘Bonner’ went marauding you knew you had a warrior on your side. He was the workhorse of the team, always in the thick of the action, winning ball and doing the donkey work, which others fed off.

Scoring wasn’t his forte, though he improved in that department as the years progressed. His essential role was that of play maker for others. It suited his personality - unpretentious and hard working. Every team needs a ‘Bonner’ type and we were fortunate to have the very best of the genre.

His fightback from serious injury in latter years typified the man.

Everyone has their favourite ‘Bonner’ moment and when I heard of his retirement my mind went back to the final seconds of the 2019 All-Ireland final. It’s deep into injury time, we’re fourteen points ahead and waiting for the final whistle. Yet ‘Bonner’ is down near the corner flag fighting like a dog to prevent a Kilkenny clearance. The warrior to the very end.

In a sense Dan McCormack had elements of the ‘Bonner’ approach too. He was another man for the arm-wrestle, always scrapping for ball and never shying away from the challenge. His tenure was shorter than ‘Bonner’s but he played a useful role at number 10 in both the ’16 and ’19 deciders.

Was there ever a better Tipperary player than Dan at winning frees? He had that strange way of wriggling in the tackle, which inevitably brought the opponent’s hurley up around his neck. Opposition players never came to terms with it; he must have been the most fouled Tipperary player of his generation.

One of Dan’s last great moments was in the 2023 championship when he did a powerful man-marking job on Limerick’s Gearoid Hegarty. We saw less of him this year and he leaves the scene now at 31, four years younger than ‘Bonner’.

Cathal Barrett is another 31-year-old who won’t be part of Liam Cahill’s panel next year, though the Holycross clubman has made it clear he’s not retiring. 2014 was his debut year, when his impact was instant.

Kilkenny under Cody had this pattern of targeting upcoming players with one of their big names, presumably with the aim of discouraging any wannabes.

In the 2014 league final Shefflin was sent in to chastise this new upstart at corner back; he quickly found out that this feisty newcomer wasn’t so easily quelled.

Two All-Irelands later - and two All-Stars - saw Barrett recognised nationally as one of the best corner backs in the business.

He hasn’t been without his controversies, however. In 2017 manager Michael Ryan dropped the Holycross man from the panel for what the County Board said at the time were “disciplinary reasons”.

This year he played a limited role in Liam Cahill’s team before being informed recently that he will not be part of the scene in 2025. A fully fit and fully focused Cathal Barrett would be an asset to any side; the management, it appears, wasn’t satisfied that either condition was properly met in 2024.

With the panel back in training, all eyes in the coming weeks will be watching for any further departures or arrivals. If the rumour mill is accurate, there will be more leaving the set-up, which raises the immediate question of who will fill the gaps.

The problem for Liam Cahill is that the back-up material is in short supply. Minor wins in ’22 and ’24 are hugely encouraging but given the age profile of such players it could take five or six years before they progress to senior level.

It all amounts to quite a bleak assessment of the immediate future. Liam Cahill and his management face an unenviable task in trying to make Tipperary competitive again.

The league format next spring will be especially challenging, with all the top teams in Division 1A; and that’s before you face the Munster round robin, with Tipperary ranked bottom of the pile at the moment.

The only way is up, I guess, but it will be testing for everyone.

Interesting to read interview comments by Dessie Hutchinson last week, where he had kind words to say about the Tipperary manager.

The question arose in relation to Davy Fitzgerald’s claim that he inherited a particularly downbeat scene in Waterford when he took over from Cahill.

It was a mean-spirited swipe at the previous manager and Hutchinson was having none of it. Cahill, in his view, did a really fine job in Waterford, including a league win over Cork in 2022. Inter-county management is a bruising business so I’m sure those comments will have been very welcome in Ballingarry.

Meanwhile, Loughmore did the double once more, their third in a dozen years. It would be remarkable to pull off such a feat once, but to do it three times is truly off the scale. It’s almost freakish.

Against Clonmel Commercials they laid the groundwork in the first half and defended it in the second on a day of big wind. It was vintage Loughmore, doggedly grinding out the win.

As a football spectacle it was typical of modern games. Let’s hope the new rules bring some improvement to a sport in serious difficulty. Massed defences, it seems to me, are the crux of the problem and while the new rules might bring some improvement, I’m not sure they’re the cure-all panacea. Teams can still employ a blanket defence, albeit with slightly fewer players.

All of that’s not meant to take from Loughmore’s win, however; they played to the existing rules and were outstanding. Liam McGrath hit some great points in the first half, as did Liam Treaacy; against the wind in the second period they simply put up the shutters.

Commercials were very disappointing. They had ample possession but couldn’t work the necessary scores. Between them the teams scored a meagre five points in the second period, which tells all you need to know about the game as a spectacle.

It was a great day too for Aherlow, as they returned to senior ranks with a deserved intermediate win over neighbours Galtee Rovers. There was a rolling back of the years here as Barry Grogan once more led the way to glory. They should erect a monument to Barry in Lisvernane, such has been his massive contribution to the club over the years. His penalty finish and that free from the Old Stand sideline were among the individual highlights that led the way on Sunday.

It was great also to see players such as Laurence Coskeran, Mark Hanley, Cathal Dillon and Thomas ‘Cooper’ Fahy being part of another great chapter in the club’s history. They were part of many great days in the past and it’s good to see them still active in the team’s return to the top tier once more.

For a very youthful looking Rovers side, there’s sure to be better days.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice