Late 'Bonner' Maher goal helps Tipperary to avoid hurling horror

Tipperary's Brian McGrath struggles to get away from Westmeath's Niall Mitchell during last weekend's game in Thurles. Picture: Michael P Ryan/Sportsfileplaceholder image
Tipperary's Brian McGrath struggles to get away from Westmeath's Niall Mitchell during last weekend's game in Thurles. Picture: Michael P Ryan/Sportsfile

Unconvincing display could come back to haunt the team

Westside brought to you in association with AALplaceholder image
Westside brought to you in association with AAL

It was the desired result but certainly not the desired performance.

Tipperary limped to victory over Westmeath in the third round of the hurling league at Semple Stadium on Saturday last. An injury-time giveaway goal from the visitors saved the hometown blushes to some extent, but hardly masked the shortcomings in Tipperary’s performance.

A patchy display from the home team saw the side go fourteen up around the three-quarter stage. That was the high point. The low point came with two David Williams goals for Westmeath and a shrivelling Tipperary lead that was eventually cut to just four points. For a fleeting moment or two we had visions of hurling horror before the visiting goalie gifted a late, late score that settled our nerves.

I must admit I expected better from some of the fringe players. This seemed the perfect stage for aspiring guys to put on a show and give Liam Cahill and colleagues a conundrum or two to unravel. It didn’t quite work out that way.

After twenty uninspiring minutes the score was seven-four to Tipperary. Just why we were standing off Westmeath and giving them so much respect was hard to fathom. Surely this was an occasion to push up and put the visitors under pressure at every opportunity. It didn’t happen.

Then, however, in the space of a few minutes we blitzed the Lake county. Andy Ormond fed Mark Kehoe for the first goal; the second was an angled sizzler from the Kilsheelan man at the end of a fine ensemble movement from way out the field. By the 27th minute we had slipped into a 2-10 to 0-5 lead and the hurling world suddenly looked secure again.

The third quarter brought no substantial change but the final phase was a major worry. Westmeath, sensing Tipp’s vulnerability, were going route one, with old fashioned high ball into the goal area. We couldn’t cope with the aerial bombardment, Barry Heffernan struggling to contain Niall Mitchell.

Eventually David Williams whipped in a goal from a goalmouth scramble and two minutes later Westmeath had a penalty. It should have been a black card also. Thankfully Rhys Shelly turned the shot away for a ‘65. It was a let-off but the bombardment continued.

Our unease near goal wasn’t helped by outfield slackness. Westmeath were winning more ball and showing greater intent. They chipped away with points and then two minutes from regulation time David Williams had their second goal. It led to a few tense, final moments before the late goal from 'Bonner' Maher that settled all issues.

It’s not exactly what we expected and, I suspect, not what Liam Cahill anticipated either. There were positives. Conor Stakelum’s return from injury has been impressive with six points from play (one should have been a goal) and a trademark, high-energy input overall. Mark Kehoe’s two goals were highlight items also. He took a first half knock and was withdrawn at half time as a precaution.

Otherwise, the return to action of Jason Forde and Noel McGrath was noteworthy. Noel turned in a typically smooth display with three points from play and an input to several others. Jason showed some rustiness, as is understandable, but he’s going to be a central cog in our efforts this season. Thereafter there were some individual items of merit but no standout displays. Cathal Quinn probably did best of the fringe players.

I hope this slack display doesn’t come back to haunt the team. There is a real danger that it might, a danger that depends on two games. If we lose to Limerick on March 9 (quite possible) and Galway defeat the Shannonsiders on March 17 (less likely), then we’ll have a huge deficit to make up in score difference. Ahead of the two remaining rounds, Limerick and Galway have score differentials of 51 points each, while ours is a mere 21 flags.

Limerick’s thrashing of Dublin was a strong statement by the Shannonsiders, albeit against a Metropolitan side that impresses nobody. John Kiely’s decision to play Kyle Hayes took me by surprise. His management of the team over the past seven years has been hugely impressive, including his handling of some difficult internal issues. This move, however, doesn’t fit the previous profile. I think it’s an error, its timing especially, which sends out all the wrong signals.

Otherwise, Cork continue to flash and fade. I thought their game with Waterford was poor in quality but interesting in its twists and turns. It’s very difficult to get a proper handle on these league games where teams are regularly short-staffed and at different stages in their training programmes.

I still have a sense that if Cork get things together with their best fifteen, they’ll be serious contenders. Likewise with Clare, who are motoring along nicely despite holding some key players in reserve. As ever Munster is going to be a bearpit when championship comes round.

Elsewhere, the GAA Congress at Newry at the weekend installed Jarlath Burns as the Association’s 41st President. He comes with a high reputation and even higher expectations after Larry McCarthy completed an undistinguished three years at the helm.

The new man has been quick to set out his stall with a promise of immediate action on areas such as the so-called three fs – finance, fixtures and football. There’s a commitment to a hurling initiative as well in a bid to spread the game to non-traditional areas. We’ll watch with interest.

His proposal for a licensing system to curb runaway team costs is an interesting initiative. Essentially a ceiling would be set on spending, with the GPA playing a central role in its implementation. Hearing examples from the Premiership soccer league must be a new departure for a GAA Congress but Jarlath wasn’t shy about referencing the case of Everton being deducted ten points for breaching their financial ceiling. Can you visualise similar sanctions in the GAA?

What wasn’t on the Congress agenda, unfortunately, was consideration of any experimental playing rules such as the hurling handpass. A motion was passed that a player who removes his helmet in future will have to leave the field before resuming play. It’s a response to a growing problem of gamesmanship in the sport but the much more urgent issue of the handpass is kicked down the road for another twelve months. Priorities! Priorities!

By coincidence (or not?) I was sent some video clips at the weekend of coaching sessions conducted by Paudie Butler and Martin Fogarty, the two highly-regarded former directors of hurling.

What you witnessed was the coaching of youngsters in the “art” of throwing the ball. In Paudie Butler’s case it was all very explicit as he repeatedly urged the players, “Throw the ball, throw the ball”. With Martin Fogarty it was more a case of omission as he coached various drills, all the while ignoring that his group of juveniles were simply throwing the ball to each other; there was no attempt to coach a proper handpass.

It's quite extraordinary that the two most highly-rated hurling coaches in the country either promote or facilitate the throwing of the ball in their coaching classes. No wonder Croke Park perceives no urgency in addressing this stain on the game.

PS. A second string Tipperary outfit played the county Under 20s recently in a challenge game. The seniors won by 3-34 to 0-8, with six of those eight flags coming from frees.

You’d expect the seniors to win, but this was wipeout territory. Some who saw the game came away shocked. Worrying indeed.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice