How many were really at the founding meeting of the GAA in 1884?


Many believe seven is the accurate number of people present at the meeting in Hayes’ Hotel in 1884, however someone has come forward with evidence to suggest this may not tell the entire story
Concerns have been raised regarding the accuracy of some of the information displayed along the new Slí Dhurlais heritage trail in Thurles, specifically relating to information surrounding the founding of the GAA on November 1, 1884, in Hayes’ Hotel.
According to an information plaque in Liberty Square, seven people attended the meeting in the billiard room, which has been a commonly accepted number for many years.
One person however has presented information that this claim may not be entirely accurate.
Tadgh Dwyer noted in a message to the Tipperary Star that newspaper reports from the time accounted for as many as 13 present at the meeting, which he says he feels is being served injustice by reports in the time since claiming that later research has found more may have been present.
He says the Tipperary Leader newspaper reported in the week following the meeting that 13 had been present at the meeting, including the original seven, as well as William Foley, TK Dwyer, Charles Culhane, William Delahunty, Michael Cantwell and John Butler.
Speaking of the six men, Dwyer says: “William Foley came from Carrick-on-Suir and was an athlete. Historian Donal McAnallen has suggested that Foley may have been a rowing colleague of Maurice Davin. That sporting connection helps explain why he may have travelled to Thurles for the meeting.
“Timothy K Dwyer of Ballyvinane, Littleton, deserves particular attention. Born in 1848, he became Ireland’s mile champion in 1878, His IRB & Land League activity and imprisonment during the Land War in 1881 and his attendance in the Charles J. Kickham funeral wake Committee and procession to Mullinahone place him firmly within the political and social life of the district.


“The Tipperary Leader printed “E Dwyer”; the Freeman’s Journal reportedly printed only “Dwyer”. In his 2015 History Ireland article, “Who was present at the founding of the GAA at Thurles in 1884?”, Historian JM Tobin argued that the name almost certainly referred to TK Dwyer. Family tradition also places TK at Hayes’s Hotel. His son Edmond gave that account to Fr Philip Fogarty in the 1930s, and Dwyer’s grandson presented research on his grandfather in the 1979 Munster Hurling Final programme. Séamus J King also included him in his 1984 centenary article, “Tipperary’s Prominence in the Gaelic Athletic Association”. The newspaper does not print his full initials, but the report, family account and later historical work together make a substantial case for recognising him.
“Charles Culhane was a Thurles athlete and businessman associated with the town’s Young Men’s Society. He later became involved in Sinn Féin activity and was imprisoned in Wormwood Scrubs. William Delahunty, from a Ballingarry family, was active in Thurles business life and had recently attended a local meeting to raise funds for William O’Brien MP. Michael Cantwell was a Thurles man associated with the Young Men’s Society.
“John Butler came from Ballyhudda in Moycarkey, contributed regularly to Tipperary newspapers and was known to the Tipperary Leader’s editor. His letters commonly gave his townland, linking him directly to the surrounding parish. TK Dwyer’s grandson, Paddy Bourke in his nineties now, lived—and still lives—on John Butler's land in Ballyhudda. He is the only surviving grandchild of a GAA founder still with us 142 years later. That continuing connection between families and place makes the omission all the more personal.”
Mr Dwyer cited a 2014 article written for History Ireland by JM Tobin, a sports writer whose research interests include athletics and pre-codified hurling, among other writers who have acknowledged more than seven attendees present at the meeting.
He said: “These names are supported by contemporary reporting and published historical research. Tobin examined the newspaper accounts in History Ireland and in “The Foundation of the Gaelic Athletic Association — A Local Perspective” in the Tipperary Historical Journal. Séamus J. King included thirteen men in his 1984 account. Donal McAnallen revisited the evidence in his Irish Examiner article of 3 November 2024, “1884–2024: The Mystery of Hayes’ Hotel and the Great GAA DNA Journey of John McKay”.
“The research of Dónal A Murphy, PJ Maxwell and Nancy Murphy. A Central Culture: Gaelic Sport in Nenagh, Volume 2, includes profiles and a transcript of the 1884 report in its appendices. Its published account states that thirteen men were present at the meeting. This is detailed local historical work by named authors, supported by documentary material. It should not be reduced to an anonymous “recent research” note.”
While the plaque in Liberty Square claims seven men attended the meeting, the Slí Dhurlais website does not state the number of men that attended the meeting.
